News

Braben: PS3 hacks "damaging to everyone", "stand against it"
Posted: 25.02.2011 12:15 by Simon Priest Comments: 6
Frontier Developments' David Braben has condemned the actions of PlayStation 3 hackers for their arrogance, and says this is not just an "academic exercise".

Sharing hack details citing 'freedom of speech' "is such rubbish," he says. All PS3 owners will suffer their actions, not just Sony. Must "roundly condemn" hackers.

Buying a PlayStation 3 console "does not give me unrestricted ownership of it," said Braben, using land ownership and planning restrictions as an example.

"If I ‘dig’ into it, I can’t just sell or even give away all the information I find. It really annoys me when hackers claim they can do what they like with what they find, especially when it is destructive to the security of all the other PS3 machines."

"These people are damaging to everyone with a PS3, not just to the games dev community, because of future security measures that will be needed, but there seems to be a blind spot amongst some players, perhaps because they imagine it will mean ‘free stuff’ in the future," he went on. Piracy has exploded on the console since the hacks.

"If someone buys the same model of car as me, and then after studying it at length announces to the world a good way of breaking into that car, it hurts me."

Certain censorship is a good thing, argues Braben: "There have been suggestions that releasing hacking information is an issue of freedom of speech. That is such rubbish. Some freedoms of speech are also curtailed for sensible reasons."

"Broadcasting easy ways of breaking into cars is bad for everyone affected, as is the freedom of speech cliché that is always wheeled out – shouting ‘Fire’ in a cinema, which creates a real risk of harm to others. It is common sense not to do it."

"There is a more subtle side to this not ‘getting’ ownership. That is the failure to acknowledge intellectual property rights, and rights to a service," he notes.

"It is all about what is reasonable. Hacking into a machine as an academic exercise is one thing. Broadcasting the information is another. We should all be prepared to roundly condemn such people. Right now it is Sony that is hurting."

"Tomorrow it will affect all of us in the development community, so we should stand against it together, now," concluded the veteran videogames designer. Frontier Developments created titles such as Kinectimals, LostWinds and RollerCoaster Tycoon.
Source: Develop

Comments

By VHugoSama (SI Core) on Feb 25, 2011
VHugoSama
Ohhh. So sorry for them, NOT! What do you say to cut the price of the games in half, that would help in the "war against piracy", Great Idea! Don't need to thank me. Lower the prices and you will have results.
P.S. I do not support Piracy by any means.
By Revan (SI Elite) on Feb 26, 2011
Revan
I hear ya VHugo, a price drop would definitely help! Paying $60 per game can be pretty damaging on the bank account after awhile.
The things we do to support our gaming and Mountain Dew addiction. :(
By VHugoSama (SI Core) on Feb 26, 2011
VHugoSama
Thats exactly right, here in Portugal most of the new games come at the astonishing starting price of "only" 70€, I don't know about you but to me thats stealing.
By chiefone (SI Veteran Member) on Feb 26, 2011
chiefone
If I don't own a PS3 when I buy it, I will not buy one. I hate the piracy and banning other peoples PS3's, but homebrew is why half of consoles sell. If a PC could only play games and not run custom software, would many people buy them?

Its not like anyone is selling proprietary PS3 code to the Chinese. We are simply loading custom software (like linux).

And I agree console games are way too expensive - even 3 or 4 year old games cost $30. If new games were $30 and older ones $15 I would probably own 50 PS3 games instead of 6.

And this is a major freedom of speech issue. Are they going to try to censor the Internet because of some root keys?
By Revan (SI Elite) on Feb 27, 2011
Revan
Problem is if we Don't pay the high $$$$$, then no more quality games. :(
The cost of making games nowadays is just so dang expensive! Heck some games cost more than movies do!
By neilmike (SI Core) on Mar 01, 2011
neilmike
i couldn't agree more, well said David Braben !!
True Any game company needs the money to make games as long as they dont get cheap on us...