Bioshock definitly deserves 9.0% the game was outstanding... I enjoyed every moment!

When it comes to graphics I would say Bioshock has got some of the best I have seen (That includes detail, texture, gore, models ect.)

The story on the other hand is good but not enough to impress me... Don't get me wrong the gameplay is amazing I enjoyed the whole game!

One thing missing to this game (that would have made it near perfect for me) is the fact that it was created for single playing only! multi playing would have put the cherry on top! (I would have liked to put my skill to the test against some of my friends here at home)