Review

Disciples III: Renaissance Review (PC)

Disciples 3 is distinctly Russian, and I don't mean that in a disparaging manner. It's a game of technical and artistic highs and mind-boggling lows, carved from a genre long-presumed dead to all but the most ardent fantasy diehards on the planet. Whilst clinging to past glory like a limpet and dragging it forwards with semi-determination, it simultaneously manages to mess up a few core elements that made its precursor widely-revered. It is, in short, a bizarre project from top to toe, but definitely one that's long-awaited by a whole bunch of people.

For those of you new to the series, this is a turn-based strategy game, best referenced alongside the likes of Kings Bounty. Your basic objective in each of the three campaigns (human, elf, demon) is to spend finite movement points on wandering an overworld map to capture territory, battle foes, or obtain loot to build up your city - which then translates directly into character upgrades and unlocked abilities. Various settlements and buildings can be claimed along the way for stat-buffing effects, and dungeons litter the landscape with the usual temptation of loot at the cost of much danger.
I hope it doesn't trip

The city, as hinted above, is the real heart of progression in Disciples, and provided you have the resources flowing in, you're granted one opportunity to build something new per turn. Building a magic tower unlocks the ability to research spells, for example, or building a guild will allow you to recruit thieves. Other buildings progress your unit types down one of several paths, allowing you to customise your party with specific tactical abilities that come in handy later in the game. This is where the strategy cocktail is at its most heady, and planning out your unit progression through the visual pleasantry of an ever-changing city is worth the install alone.

Complementing that, each of Disciples' maps is packed to the brim with content and a good level of detail. Splitting your party into two (fresh leaders and party members are recruited at your main city), enables quicker traversal and discovery of terrain, but at the cost of precious resources. Is it better to save your money for a lumbering Titan in your main party or to create a fresh group and open up battle on a new front? If nothing else, it seeds the game with a multi-faceted approach to strategy, and that's a welcome addition for those that like to add a dash of flair to their well thought-out plans.

Beware the large and angry thing


Not that flair is particularly welcome in Disciples' grim world of course, where even the traditional fantasy trappings are layered on with a reverence that's quite unusual. It wants to be a serious and almost contemplative game, but it conveys that solely through dark gothic graphical stylings, a sombre tone, and an occasionally evocative orchestral soundtrack. When it works - and if you're able to get a little bit of the Linkin Park spirit past your defences - it's a thing of beauty; but when the gameplay pulls you out of the moment, it's the sort of design that ends up a little embarrassing for all concerned.

And unfortunately for the majority of strategy veterans out there, Disciples' combat engine will pull you out of the experience with relative frequency. 

Battles now take place in scenic hex-filled arenas, with units initially lining up according to the group formation specified in your city. Movement ranges for each character are clearly marked, and then combat is a traditional affair that consists of manoeuvring your ranged units out of danger and your melee characters into the fight - or alternatively located as strategic cover for anybody taking a battering. Various power tiles litter the arena to accentuate damage or attributes when attacked from, and boulders, trees and other detritus block routes and create choke points to exploit tactically.

Where Titans hang out in the evening

But those same rocks that block movement somehow fail to halt arrows and other missiles that magically travel straight through, whilst the power tiles are almost exclusively used by human players, with the AI seemingly unaware of their existence for the majority of the time. As a result of the apparent lack of depth here, battles are either ludicrously easy via way of kamikaze tactics from your opponents, or viciously difficult thanks to a few lucky criticals at the start that throw the balance completely out of favour. Combat is disengaging as a result and never quite feels fair; and that applies either when winning or taking a heavy loss.

With the majority of the game revolving around that system, it's a shame that the developer couldn't polish things to a higher shine, as the rest of the material deserves at least a little better. For all its faults though, Disciples is certainly something unique, and the quality of the overworld sections and general strategising may well be enough for a crowd that will inevitably seek it out anyway. If that's you, you can add at least a point onto the score. For everybody else, your curiosity might pay off.

Best Game Moment:  Crushing any weakling with a mighty Titan

Videos

Comments

By bosnian_dragon (SI Core) on Jul 24, 2010
bosnian_dragon
I haven't played turn-based RPG in a long time. The last one I played was Age of Wonders Shadow Magic, and it was brilliant. This reminds me of Heroes V though.
By BoneArc (SI Elite) on Jul 26, 2010
BoneArc
Heroes of might and magic was better Then this , my opinion.
By bosnian_dragon (SI Core) on Jul 26, 2010
bosnian_dragon
@ Bone Arc, I agree, nothing compares to HOMM :) I was just comparing the genres that's all, and HOMM is the supreme one in this genre.
By Mercy (SI Core) on Jul 30, 2010
Mercy
Turn based AH! That makes me sick plus the games not good (No surprise) I only go for the live action to begain with.
By BoneArc (SI Elite) on Aug 04, 2010
BoneArc
@ Bosnian
ya i know , HoMM is the GAME when it come to Turn based strat.
@Mercy i like live action too , with headset , an FPS owns . pumps the adrenaline a bit , but real life shooters would own
By Wowerine (SI Elite) on Aug 05, 2010
Wowerine
HOMM should get a revision btw. It's been a while.
By BoneArc (SI Elite) on Aug 06, 2010
BoneArc
yea , i kind of miss the franchise ...
Why dont they make a next gen version of it ?
By HARDY124 (SI Veteran Member) on Aug 10, 2010
HARDY124
Are U Always On Ur Horse!!!in This Game
By bosnian_dragon (SI Core) on Aug 11, 2010
bosnian_dragon
HoMM sucked in their fifth release. For me, personally, HoMM 3 and HoMM Chronicles were the most significant releases of the franchise. Homm IV was good, but the HoMM V was a total dissapointment for me. 3d and turn-based fantasy games are too much for me.
By Pototox (SI Core Member) on Aug 20, 2010
Pototox
I like this game so bad...

@bosnian_dragon yep... HOMM V sucked big time...
By Wowerine (SI Elite) on Aug 21, 2010
Wowerine
HoMM V had a nice expansion tough. It did suck yeah, but really wasn't that bad. Maybe because it was my first HoMM game.